User blog comment:Markurion/How many of you put a bullet in Godchild in EC?/@comment-4672495-20120721205909/@comment-2228120-20120722161058

@LilyheartsLiara: Has it ever occured to you that people may be genuine in their differing perception of the ending? That their gaming preferences may be nuanced towards aspects which you consider minor, and approach it from a perspective which is very different from yours but may still be perfectly legitimate? In this respect, analysing a game is not very different from literary analysis, and this is a field where, based on the same facts, people can arrive at various alternatives of reading, and none of them being exactly wrong. Would it be really so difficult to stop assuming that people criticise the ending out of some inborn malevolence, or that their negative opinion somehow constitutes an offence to yours by its very existence?

If you're so hard convinced that everything in the ending is self-explanatory, then place yourself in the position of a teacher who simply has to get the message through, no matter what she may think of the mental abilities of her students, and give it a try. Otherwise it would seem that you are merely trying to avoid the answer, because you don't have any.

I've asked you to put up a blog to adress the issue, since it's quite extensive, but if you'd prefer going point by point, it's fine with me. So:

Where in the ending, or anywhere throughout the series, do the geth (and not heretics) or EDI express a wish to eradicate all organic life, to give credence to the Catalyst's claim that this will inevitably happen?