User blog comment:The Milkman/Extended Expectations, Part II/@comment-147.26.199.70-20120627235228/@comment-4950455-20120628021630

Honestly, I think it would hurt if it comes at the expense of people who didn't make that decision. Mass Effect certainly can have things play out quite differently depending on how the player chooses, but with a very few exceptions those choices have been treated as equally valid.

The issue of whether the EC could have gone into more detail on the ultimate fates of the Normandy crew is a more ambiguous one, but I stand by my position that the lack of a reunion scene does not constitute an "utter lack of closure". It doesn't even come close.