User blog comment:Ygrain/How the ending might make sense/@comment-1900300-20120614140614

I concur with your ideas for the most part, but your theory is not about having the existing ending make sense. Rather it is, as a famous Jedi would say "the truth from a certain point of view" i.e. lying through your teeth. This theory ignores everything or assumes it to mean something else to work. It makes hugh assumtions about the nature of the ending and the intention of the writrs and completely rewrites the reasoning and motivation of the Reapers.

In short, this is a fan made ending with nothing to do with the original short of changing it to make sense of a theory. It is no more or less then another theory like the IT. It is much better thought out and interesting, but notheless it does not do what you claim it does in the title.