User blog comment:-Algol-/Of policies, admins and the community/@comment-217683-20130129082243/@comment-4319257-20130131211338

"The majority of that last comment was either flat-out wrong, just plain nonsensical"

To return the courtesy: you disagreeing with those points doesn't make them neither "flat out wrong", nor "nonsensical".

About the technical impossibility. What I meant, was it was practically impossible for Ygrain to contact each and every user of this wiki. You say she should have contacted a random bunch? Well, no. Nothing and noone obliged her to inform the users in this particular way. She can talk to whoever she wants to.

About slandering. Read her post and reply.

About Ygrain contacting people from "other sites". I assume you noticed, that ME wiki and DA wiki are affiliated. In theory that is implied for increasing traffic between both sites. In this way people are actually encouraged to visit both sites. And if they wish to involve themselves in particular affairs, like voting, they can. Not to mention that every user voting for or against the policy was a user of this site. Really, this whole "other site" fallacy you and Legionwrex seem to hold so dear by constantly referring to it is nothing but a very poor excuse. Then again, you are running out of excuses, aren't you?

About Ygrain "canvassing" or "soliciting" voters. Your dictionaries, your real-life experiences are simply irrelevant. Commdor's precedent doesn't hold a clear definition. THAT is what would have applied here, not dictionaries. And if it isn't defined, derp, you can't ban people for non-defined "misdeeds". Well, you can't ban them fairly, that is.

About you assuming Ygrain's intents. I commend your well-developed imagination, but please, keep it to yourself, while you decide to ban people or not. You don't ban people basing on assumptions. Of course, if you want to ban them fairly.

"the Wikia system is not a democracy"

Nice one, nice one.

But as for your answer, thank you. I'll comment that above, this conversation is getting a bit cluttered.