User blog comment:JakePT/Lair of the Shadow Broker is INCREDIBLE/@comment-2174252-20100911005604/@comment-1691295-20100911045834

Double checked my saves, looks like before Lair of the Shadow Broker I had 99% and after I had 100%.

I must have checked after the choice, wondering why I couldn't unlock it, and seen that it said 100% and assumed it was like that before. Seeing as I took the non-Intimidate Renegade option I must have been bumped up to 100% with that choice.

False alarm. I guess you need 100% for either choice.