User blog comment:The Milkman/Reaper Logic/@comment-24174486-20120719203102/@comment-4237253-20120720054431

I think Bob Case (MrBtongue on YouTube) has already proven that the anti-ending moment does not rely solely on ignorance. He is an extremely intelligent person who broke down why the ending is broken, from literary, business, moral, and gameplay standpoints. I would instead say that defending the ending, or rather saying we are out of place in criticising it, is ignorance in itself.

The ending is poorly written. The writer(s) made terrible decisions and made amateurish mistakes. I am willing to bet a good sum of currency that most of the commenters here could have written a better ending. You don't need a background as a writer to understand the huge flaws in the ending; it doesn't do what endings are supposed to do.