User blog comment:Kaloneous/Mass Effect 3 Ending DLC Denied and PAX/@comment-4933332-20120401055525/@comment-4933332-20120401063250

I think he loaded the actual map but went in free roam mode. The area that looks unfinish is because he flown into areas that weren't fully rendered but as far as I know these are teh actual map.

Yes, the video wasn't trying to disprove the entire theory, just the main one about the shepard breathing must be on earth and there isn't any other reasonable interpretation. For some people that was the smoking gun, there are people who said they only suspected the indoctrination theory after seeing shepard live ending.

The thing people have to realised is that you can't disprove the indoctrination theory because a lot of it is based on speculation.

A lot of people respond to critique of indoctrination theory with saying that your attempted debunk was just speculation as well (both blogs that tried to debunk the theory, including the one I posted as well as the one kaloneous posted, used alternative speculation and interpretation of subjective events)

Which is fine, no one would have an issue if people accept it was speculation and individual interpretation. The whole idea of some of the debunk is it combats the idea that these points, the only way to interpret it is the indoctrination theory, alternative interpertation are objectively wrong. As long as you have one reasonable alternative interpreataion that is logical, then it disproves that point as an objective evidence supporting the theory.