User blog comment:Lancer1289/Gamespot Releases Reader's Choices/@comment-217683-20110112024115/@comment-217683-20110112042318

Reach had better writing, but it lacks the replay-ability of RDR, which is a big aspect of whether or not a game is good. As for phenomenal or not, I do think RDR is no worse than, and possibly a little better than, ME2, but then again, that's my opinion.

As for zombies, BioWare doesn't need to come out with a zombie pack. Unlike RDR, ME and ME2 already have zombies. They're called husks. So, if zombies are your issue, you should like RDR, shouldn't you? I mean, unlike ME and ME2, in RDR, zombies are strictly optional! :P