User blog comment:JakePT/Lair of the Shadow Broker is INCREDIBLE/@comment-2174252-20100911005604/@comment-2174252-20100911174224

I’m pretty sure the Renegade was available with the Paragon grayed out. I took the Renegade choice but I can't remember the exact wording when Sheppard talks about killing the Council. The rest of the exchange is the same as the Paragon choice.

I will restart the mission from a prior save and run it again with the same character. I’ll keep you posted.