User blog comment:Legionwrex/Genophage good or bad./@comment-1900300-20100922020335/@comment-217683-20100922045608

Yeah, no doubt. I never meant the A-bomb to be a straight-up "these two events are analogous" thing. As I've stated, it was meant more as an "while the specifics are different, the underlying arguments of morals and necessity in wartime are comparable" thing.

And you are, IMHO, spot on with the entirety of your post, particularly the excellent second paragraph.