User blog comment:Markurion/How many of you put a bullet in Godchild in EC?/@comment-5271559-20120718235017/@comment-2228120-20120719050241

Yeah? And on what events did the Catalyst base its claim that the synthetics would wipe out all organics? Apparently, his creators did encounter the problem, but their synthetics were unsuccessful (until the Catalyst succeeded). After that, the Catalyst created the cycles, from which he cannot derive any reliable data, either, since he basically interrupts the development and has NO way of knowing what would have happened otherwise. As for the geth - did you forget that they COULD have wiped out the quarians during the Morning War but didn't and that you can even broker peace? That EDI did start like a machine on a killing spree but evolved into something very different? These are points that both the Catalyst and Bioware seem to ignore, and from THESE I infer that the Catalyst's solution is flawed, since it doesn't take into account ALL the variables. A theory to which there are exceptions is a flawed theory.