User blog comment:Killerkidzz78/Star Wars VS The Reapers/@comment-180.183.108.108-20120908093746/@comment-4721065-20120908095830

Actually, it's a lot closer to the opposite. The Star Wars shields are completely useless against physical objects, which is why it is possible to fly through them and the Chewbacca bowcaster isn't completely outdated. On the other hand, the ME shields/barriers CAN block energy attacks: the latter only have a modest bonus against them. Finally, given the incredible precision of ME targeting computers and the enormous range advantage, the Star Destroyers wouldn't have a chance: Reapers would melt their cockpit in the first shot and destroy the rest of the ship at their leisure, safe from attacks all along.