User blog comment:Markurion/How many of you put a bullet in Godchild in EC?/@comment-1854594-20120718193300/@comment-4950455-20120718234010

Well, of course Synthesis is totally ridiculous from a scientific standpoint. And I've been very vocal about finding the Catalyst's logic unconvincing. The point is not that the current ending, with or without the Extended Cut, is perfect - rather, it's that it's unbelievably presumptuous to say that it's a "slap in the face" for Bioware not to use your personal fan-made ending, regardless of that ending's quality.

I honestly believe that I could make an ending that's genuinely better - in at least some respects, anyway - then the current one. But would I be offended if Bioware doesn't use it or anything like it? Of course not; that would be the height of presumption.

@LilyheartsLiara: I don't really disagree with your assessment of the Refusal people, but the fact remains that not giving the players the ability to make the choice they want - even if it's basically a galaxy-dooming hissy fit - in a series that prided itself on player choice is both silly and wrong.