User blog comment:The Milkman/Extended Expectations, Part II/@comment-2250460-20120628002222/@comment-4950455-20120628003902

Under those terms, I'd say Control is better - given some of the new details the Catalyst gives, I don't think the Reapers helping of their own accord is really as good as it sounds. Those things need to be put down for good.

It's also worth noting that ReaperGod!Shepard draws a clear distinction between itself and Shepard as we knew hir. So what extent it can be said that Shepard's "still alive" is debatable.

For the record, I picked Control this time around.