User blog comment:Leviathan2186/Samara vs Jack vs Aria?/@comment-36.71.172.141-20131231042816

Anyone of them could win, depending on who gets the jump on who first. But if it's only math, Samara, definitely.

Jack is powerful, but she's a blunt instrument, great at wrecking but she has not much experience fighting a powerful, smart and skillful enemy. Experience wise, she's also young. The naturally long living Asari would most likely have advantage in terms of battle experience. In duel against either Aria or Samara, Jack will be defeated rather easily due to lack of skill and experience.

Aria seems to be right material for a fierce combatant, but her scope's rather limited: her interest is to rule Omega, she's spent hundreds of years ruling Omega where she met virtually no challenge. She could have grown rather decadent as result. But if the battle takes place in Omega, then Aria wins, no contest. She's master of her home ground. But this battle's to take place in a neutral ground so it all comes down mostly to her power, skill and experience. She's good, but Samara beats her here.

Now Samara? As Justicar she's living embodiment of discipline, she's used to live in hardship. Her focus would be fearsome. She's also nearly a thousand years old and has raw biotics about equal level as an Asari Matriach. Her quest as Justicar has her continuously travel the galaxy, seeking combat, and sometimes against powerful dangerous foes (eg: Spectre Nihlus), so she just keep on piling battle experience like nuts. Her Justicar Code, while source of her strength, can also be exploited to be her weakness however, just as Nihlus did to escape her. So in battles of intrique and wits, Aria could win. But here we're talking about pure combat and no tricks. Samara's the most powerful contender here, I'd place a large bet on her.