User blog comment:Milky544/Jack and Miranda./@comment-76.169.171.233-20120803135659

You need very high paragon for the argument to be settled like stated. However, this confrontation actually requires less renegade to unlock,	(still needs to be high though.) If you passed Tali and Legions check, its because it requires less paragon than renegade, although, it IS much later in the game. To settle the argument's afterward by choosing a side, you'll need to have the same paragon or renegade that was initial for the argument.