How can you compare the two?

EDI’s voice was way better.

SAM humor was drier than a desert.

SAM was so boring. I would rather listen to 1 hour of addison

SAM was a wiser idea, make this thing corporeal so that is has something in common with humanity.

@Burningcherry97 EDI were more corporeal than SAM

EDI was not required to be implanted in my character's head (cooperatively or not) to develop a grasp of humanity.

@Lethal blade00 After thinking, you're probably right. But SAM existed in some way in a human body and that puts it a bit closer to humanity IMO.

Geth.