Talk: Romance

Listing Romances in Mechanics Section

It's not as redundant as someone pointed out, because only 3 characters will grant the 'paramour' achievement, and the romances for Kelly Chambers and Morinth do not follow the other rules. I would repeat them as it is a source of confusion, especially if someone actually intends to romance Kelly/Morinth. I strongly think these should be repeated in the mechanics to resolve that confusion, that's why I put them in there.Killswitch19 03:06, February 5, 2010 (UTC) can you actually have sex with the consort?

It's implied sex, but yes. If you seem disatisfied ("That's it?") with her reward for helping with the turian general, she steps in close and there's a cutscene of her hand sliding down a steamy window. IGN Video--avfanatic (talk) 04:12, 26 November 2007 (UTC)

Reminds me of that scene from Titanic.... what? No one else saw that? Is it possible for the two main female characters (if you play as male Sheppard) to get into a catfight? Kap2310 21:19, 10 December 2007 (UTC)

I'm not clear on the Romance plot. How do you have a relationship with someone other than Liara? Example, Kaidan. When do I rescue Liara? Does that matter? What if I just never talk to her?(talk) 11:48, 28 February 2008 (UTC)

The beginning of the "Romance" subplot begins on Eden Prime, when you, Kaiden and Ashley find the beacon. Whichever teammate is your opposite gender (male > Ashley; female > Kaiden), he/she will activate the beacon and you will save him/her. Later, in the infirmary, he/she'll apologize for getting in harms way and tell you that they carried you back to the ship. Give the Paragon answer for both statements and he/she will give you a look of interest. Next, immediately go rescue Liara. After you do so, begin talking to your chosen love interest repeatedly. As you complete Assignments/Missions, he/she will start dropping subtle hints of their interest in you. Generally, giving a Paragon answer will almost always ensure that you pursue their interest. Eventually, though, you will have to make a choice between your human love interest and Liara. From this point onward, there's almost no way to fail the Romance subplot, except by refusing sex on the night it's offered or letting your love interest die on Virmire. King Zeal 19:47, 28 February 2008 (UTC)

Confusion

Extremely Confusing - The main page states that if you talk to Liara after initiating the romance with either Kaiden or Ashley that the next time you speak with them they will ask you how you feel about Liara. In my case this was not true at all. Ashley mentioned Liara but no choice was given. However, Liara blatantly asks you if you are interested in Ashley. Now the main page says that if you show interest in the other party it will end the relationship with the one you're talking to and since I hadn't yet seen the confrontation I wanted to romance both of them. Going by what the main page says I told her we were just friends. Apparently unless you say "Ash is special" your romance with Ashley is over. Not only did Ash not ask me how I felt about Liara but going by what the main page said and not telling Liara that Ash was special somehow ended my relationship. There's no way for somebody to know that you can end your romance with Ashley while talking to Liara. I'll admit this is a mistake on the developers part but I think the main page should plainly warn users of such an easy screw up. It's a bit odd for you to be talking to someone about your feelings for each other and your plans after Saren is gone and all of a sudden you never speak of such things again without a conversation. I'm pretty angry about this if you can tell. Thoughts anyone?--Loscakes 17:45, 15 August 2009 (UTC)

There seems to be a particular point in the relationship when you can sort of string both of them along, but it's a hard note to hit. It seems to be dependent on whether you've just done a major mission, and which order you're speaking to them in; if you tell Liara you're not interested, for example, Kaidan won't ask if you're interested in Liara. There's also a bug I've encountered where, you pick the bottom option and definitively tell Liara you're not interested, she basically blatantly ignores you and still acts as if you're romancing her. So maybe you're right; that section of this page needs to be rewritten for clarity to explain this. I'm sorry if it caused you problems but I agree, the romance path is sometimes a little muddied.

I think the litmus test is this: if, when you say goodbye, your romance calls you "Shepard" or says "I'd like that" about talking again, or something, you're good and still in a romance. If they call you "Commander", it's over. --Tullis 18:14, 15 August 2009 (UTC)

Don't be sorry this is a great guide. The only alteration I would recommend is to be sure to tell Liara that Ashley/Kaiden is special whether you plan on romancing Liara or not. Otherwise your relationship with the human will end with that one dialogue. Bioware dropped the ball on this one. They made it as if Liara immediately runs to engineering and tells Ashley what that you said they were just friends and Ashley just takes it on faith and never speaks to you about it again. I had to go back to a save 10 hours back and sure enough when I told Liara that Ashley was special rather then we were just friends my romance with Ashley didn't end like it did before. They sure do make it 100x easier to romance Liara.--Loscakes 17:14, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

Ye-ess... there's more than a hint of 1950s "show me more of this Earth thing called kissing" about Liara, I have to admit. Her attraction does seem very foisted on the player. While Shepard at least has a few things in common with Ash and Kaidan, Liara doesn't actually seem to have any reason for falling for Shepard -- enough to decide to have her first sexual encounter with Shepard, I might add -- apart from being rescued which, I agree, is a powerful motivator. However, Shepard is also the one who helped kill Liara's mother, and if you do Noveria before ever meeting Liara, she never asks you to explain it, and is still eager to talk about how asari do the deed. Makes it sort of uncomfortable. --Tullis 18:06, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

0 Paragon Romance?

Is it possible to complete a romance without getting Paragon points? Romancing Ashley for example awards Paragon points for "favorable" choices. So is it possible to get a romance with 0 Paragon points at Illos? 165.21.154.72 13:03, 12 January 2008 (UTC)

Why would you want to do that? It's not that Paragon points hurt even when you play Renegade style. And if you do, your Renegade bar will be at 100% on Ilos anyway. --84.57.115.162 23:39, 12 January 2008 (UTC)

It's good to know that you never actually lose points in either direction if you do one or the other. They both simply add up.

On recieving the Cipher.

"On Feros, when Shepard is given the Cipher, the love interest looks concerned and wants to know if the commander is okay"

I don't think this is especially limited to the love interest. When I take Garrus with me, he acts all concerned and asks if I'm okay as well. Maybe this is just relative to who you have in your team and in which order (chosen 1st or 2nd in your party)? --Digital Holocaust 13:06, 16 July 2008 (UTC)

• I don't find anything wrong with that statement... Skarmory The PG 23:20, 25 November 2008 (UTC)

Alternate route?

I'm curious, but not enough to check myself...

Has anybody chosen this path: Is it possible to pick a human over Liara, lose them on Virmire, and then start a romance with the Asari? It makes sense dramatically, the going for comfort and all that. - Skarmory The PG 23:20, 25 November 2008 (UTC)

My b/f got that option, but only because he hadn't made the effort to really shoot Liara down beforehand. --Tullis 23:33, 25 November 2008 (UTC)

Fox news

Near the end of one of the paragraphs it said somewheres basically 20 second sex scene in a 20 hour long game. I beat the game in exactly 11 Hr. 14 Min. 52 Sec. Eat popscicles Fox News! *Cough*I did Ashley*Cough*-CORTEZSNIPER! HUZZAH! 17:07, 2 January 2009 (UTC)

Do we need a transcript of the video? It seems it would be better if we just talked about the segment and included a link to the video? Dweller93 04:14, 28 July 2009 (UTC)

Removing list of books

Sorry but I've removed the list of Lawrence's books and their Amazon listings--I don't want to give this woman publicity she doesn't deserve. --Tullis 21:29, 10 April 2009 (UTC)

I seriously doubt anyone is going to read this then buy those books - if anything it will hurt her because when people google her or/and the book names this will hopefully come up so people can see behind the PR facade :) I've changed it back for now but if you still think it's going to help her in any way after this feel free to do whatever and reply again! But I am serious it won't don't worry. The links are also useful for people that want to review her too (the amazon site doesn't have a list of books by her you can only search and get tonnes of results for people that aren't her) >:)

If you think I'm out to spam for her or anything just check the history I'm the one that added the explanation of what "misspoke" means ;) --kittenofdoom 01:28, 11 April 2009 (UTC)

I know you're not spamming for her, but sorry, I'm going to remove them again. Firstly it doesn't really fit with our neutrality as a wiki, and secondly, though I endorse people's right to express themselves, I'm not going to endorse one-starring... because we're better than her. :) --Tullis 01:56, 11 April 2009 (UTC)

Music

"If Shepard's love interest is sacrificed on Virmire (after a developed relationship), after the debrief the romance theme will play instead of the Normandy's background music, until the Galaxy Map is used again." – I just had Kaidan die on Virmire, with a male Shepard, and the romance music played on the Normandy. So the previous sentence can't be entirely true – well, I guess it technically is, since the sentence didn't say "iff", but there must be some additional criterion. I did have Shepard go out of his way to make friends with Kaidan, though…maybe that's it? ShepardWhyThisJubilee 07:17, 9 August 2009 (UTC)

Hm, maybe. Though it's never happened when I've played a female Shepard, and sacrificed Ashley after making friends with her. How odd. --Tullis 13:54, 9 August 2009 (UTC)

I don't think that the music has anything to do with the romance subplot. The music change is to enhance the tragedy, and to show the impact of the character death - the same reason for the change in Joker's voice when he asks Shepard if he wants to contact the council. --silverstrike 16:07, 25 August 2009 (UTC)

And then I played as a female Shepard again, and didn't get the romance music after Ashley died! I think it played during the debriefing scene itself, but didn't continue to become the Normandy background music like it did that previous time. Weird. ShepardWhyThisJubilee 22:29, February 9, 2010 (UTC)

What did Ashley want to say and where did she say?

After the sex scene Ashley says: "Hey, Shepard? Whatever happens down there, I just wanted to say... Wait. You know what? I'm not telling you. You wan't to hear this, you'll just have to come back to me." But I never figured what she wanted to say. Is it just forgetten to say in the game or am I blind? And somewhere the have to say 'Yeah, well if you want me in a tin foil mini skirt and thigh-high boots, I'm gonna need dinner first... Uh... sir...'. But where and when? Roytjuh

Three little words. Do I really have to spell it out for you? 71.101.142.163 04:27, April 22, 2010 (UTC)

Playing as a male Shepard, after you first go to the Citadel and are told to track down either Barla Von or Harkin, don't pick up Wrex and Garrus right away. Go with Ash and Kaidan down to the Wards, and go up to the large window in the middle (directly across from one of the Ward accesses, I forget which one. It's the large window behind Emily Wong, anyway.) Look out at the view, and pick Paragon responses. She should say it then. --Tullis 20:34, 26 August 2009 (UTC)

ME / ME2 split

I vote we clear out the ratings issue sections, leave a link to where it's documented on Wikipedia if we want to, then split this page into Mass Effect romances and ME2 romances. --Tullis 16:37, October 9, 2009 (UTC)

I second that. The whole sex scene/ratings controversy isn't really that relevant to the Mass Effect universe and reads just a wee bit vehement. Maybe the format of the section could be changed a little too, possibly by character. --TheWilsonator 16:47, October 9, 2009 (UTC)

ME 2 reference

Since I know people don't always check the history for this stuff, I'm going to repeat it here (even though they also don't always check the talk pages first... boo!) It IS CONFIRMED that your love interest from Mass Effect will NOT BE A SQUADMATE in ME2. For confirmation of this, refer to the Holiday '09 edition of the Official XBox Magazine, page 23, in the "Mass Effect 2: 5 Biggest Rumors- Debunked" article. I'll post the relevant section in it's entirety:

• Rumor #4: I can't have my old love interest in my squad- Your love interest from Mass Effect is definitely part of the story in Mass Effect 2. However, the squad you form in Mass Effect 2 is joining you on a suicide mission, so odds are high that many of them won't survive the ending. Because the love story that began in the first game will continue to the end of the trilogy (if you want it to), we wanted to make sure these important characters would survive Mass Effect 2.

That, btw, was from Casey Hudson. So I think it's fair to say it's legit. :) SpartHawg948 06:03, December 23, 2009 (UTC)

Is it possible to refuse but still keep the romance?

Is it possible to just refuse the sex when offered but still keep the romance until the end??

If you are talking about the events of the 1st game, then no, the romance will not be complete unless it is consummated. H-Man Havoc 12:20, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

ME2 FemShep romances

The Best Buy chat with Casey Hudson link pretty much says flat out (the answer appears right after the halfway point of the chat log) that there won't be any f/f romances in ME2. Since it seems that he reserves the term "female" for humans of the female gender (he calls quarians "female-looking but asexual"), this would seem to rule out Miranda, Subject Zero, or Kelly Chambers (though he notes that she "isn't necessarily a love interest") as FemShep romance options. That said, it pretty much leaves everyone else on the squadmember list (everyone revealed to this point anyway) as possibles, not to mention any other non-squaddie, non-human-female characters as yet unrevealed. Derint 00:14, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

It's probably a likely scenario that a female Shepard can have a romance with Samara, assuming she is available to, as she is an Asari and it happened with Liara in the first game. There was only one f/f romance in the first game, so that's probably the case with this game. H-Man Havoc 01:26, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

I think he misspoke. As we know there are "male" and "female" quarians I think the reference was directed towards asari. Who while looking female aren't really.--Xaero Dumort 01:45, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

I think the whole situation is strange. It's not as if there is a taboo about it in video games. As long as a potential scene remains short and not very revealing, similar to a certain scene in ME1, then it should be added in. What does Bioware have to lose if it decides to start a bit of a precedent. I heard they did strange things in Dragon Age: Orgins, but nothing's strange here. H-Man Havoc 05:02, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

I get the feeling like there was an alien same-sex (kinda) relationship in ME1, there will be one in ME2, but this time it will be Thane that can be romanced by both genders. The German (or was it Polish, I can't remember) voice of Shepard said in an interview a while back that there is a male-male Romance this time, and it wouldn't surprise me if they went the same way they did with ME1 and have that relationship be with an alien.JakePT 05:36, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

I guess that would tie in to what happens in Dragon Age: Origins, as it is possible to initiate a male/male romance in that game.H-Man Havoc 13:05, January 14, 2010 (UTC)

But that was an elf! You can't count elves as real men! :P SpartHawg948 11:28, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

Miranda

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5fQwgzYQ7Vc

Is 0:27-0:30 enough to add Miranda at this time? You can see a tiny bit of what looks like Shepard's forehead.

JakePT 10:42, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

I'm going to have to say no. You can see a tiny bit of what looks like Shepard's forehead. Hardly confirmation. SpartHawg948 10:49, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

Regardless.... Damn, that part's still sexy. On another note, it could be Shepard's forehead. H-Man Havoc 12:23, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

It could be. I never said it wasn't, just that it isn't for certain. Or, as you put it, it could be Shepards forehead. (thanks to you two, btw. I love it when all I have to do to make my point is quote what you said and add some strategically placed emphasis. That wasn't me trying to be snide or rude, either, I intend that to be read at face value.) Until we get something more definitive than a split-second something that could be Shepard's forehead, and that looks like Shepard's forehead, something more along the lines of a statement of confirmation from someone at BioWare, we don't have confirmation. And given that Casey Hudson totally dodged the question and refused to answer it when brought up at the recent Best Buy Q&A, I doubt we'll be getting that statement prior to the 26th. SpartHawg948 12:30, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

YEAH ALL NIGHT GAMMING!!! MPS Biotic 21:46, January 16, 2010 (UTC)

It's been confirmed that the "forehead" in the Youtube video is that of Commander Shepard. This is confirmed through the "Sci vs. Fi" documentary, specifically part 3 of the overall program. Here is the link:

http://www.gametrailers.com/video/exclusive-sci-mass-effect/60957

I just hope she could be a love interest for a femShep. H-Man Havoc 23:06, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

That's fine. If there's an actual source (I'm waiting till the Sci vs Fi airs out here in 5 hours to find out) then include the information AND THE SOURCE in the article. The problem is that people just want to insert that it's confirmed that she's a romance option with absolutely zero evidence/sourcing to support it. People need to realize that when they add new info about a forthcoming game, they need to add the sources themselves. They can't expect everyone else to do their homework for them or pick up their slack. SpartHawg948 23:12, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

The source IS gametrailers.com, which unless I'm wrong, doesn't provide written sources to its videos. They simply are showing advance viewings of the program before its actual airing. There is another part of the vid that is not yet available for viewing on that site (Part 4/4), I'm waiting for that, as because I'm in Canada, the CRTC (Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission) effectively prevents the Syfy network from being aired in that country. H-Man Havoc 23:25, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

Again, that's fine if gametrailers.com is the source. Notice I never questioned that. What I was talking about was the spate of edits we've had where people have added in the Miranda is a confirmed romance with NO SOURCE WHATSOEVER, gametrailers.com or no. If you re-read what I said (and actually read it) you'll see that this is what I said from the get-go. If there is a video that elaborates on the romance scene, great. If it's just the one that shows the snippet that might be Shepard's forehead, not so great. But again, my issue was inserting new info with no source whatsoever. SpartHawg948 23:32, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

Oh, alright. Point Taken. H-Man Havoc 23:35, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

Old Squad, New romance.

I dont know why, but my posted how people from the ME:1 squad that couldnt be romanceable can be in ME:2 got taken down, but Im glad someone re-added it.

Anyways, the Director dude said that those squadmates can be romanceable. Could it be Tali and Garrus? They are the only two characters from the old squad that stays involved with you in the new game.

I don't know why it was taken down either. If only there was some way for people to summarize their edits, then we'd know. Wait, nevermind! THERE IS A WAY TO SUMMARIZE EDITS! And what's more, I DID provide an edit summary stating EXACTLY WHY your edits were removed. It was, and I quote (or you could just check the page history) "screwed up the images, and this is info that is already known, and stated above". As I stated there, your edits screwed up the image formatting and didn't contribute anything. No one "re-added it", they added new info. All you did was state that there were going to be some characters returning from the first game who would be romanceable, which was info that was already know, and stated above the bit you added... kind of like what I put in my summary. Now it says that there are characters returning from the first game that you couldn't romance then, but can romance now. See the difference? So, that in a nutshell is why your post was removed and not re-added. SpartHawg948 01:18, January 18, 2010 (UTC)

I sense a lot of animosity in your posts for the last couple of weeks while I browse around this wiki SpartHawg. No offense but calm down and re-assess your situation. Peace. 24.87.4.53 03:20, January 18, 2010 (UTC)

Sorry. It just gets really frustrating having to explain basic concepts like edit summaries. It took all of 5 seconds to determine why your original edit was removed, less time than it took to ask the question here. It can get a bit trying. However, not really sure about all the supposed animosity in my posts. Most of my posts lately have been as polite, civil, and restrained as usual. If you care to cite specific posts, I'd be happy to take a look at them. I don't see the need to calm down, as I'm not excited or worked up at the moment, and I see no need to re-assess my situation, as that would imply there is something wrong with my current situation, a premise you've offered no evidence to support. And for the record, I am a big supporter of peace, it's just that I adhere to the philosophy of "Peace through superior firepower". :) SpartHawg948 03:29, January 18, 2010 (UTC)

• Fair enough. I expressed doubt that I had shown a trend of animosity in my posts (excluding obvious momentary frustration over issues such as having to explain to people the concepts of edit summaries and page histories), but conceded that it may have been possible that I did show such a trend of animosity. I asked for specific examples so that, if I had displayed any such animosity I could concede that I had been mistaken and make amends to any who were treated unfairly. I gave time for said examples to be provided, none have thus far been forthcoming, leading me to conclude that I was correct in doubting the supposed trend of animosity. SpartHawg948 23:40, January 19, 2010 (UTC)

I guess Tali is confirmed now. http://www.justin.tv/clip/d1c971eca86838b0

Nope, not quite. All that video shows is Tali saying she will try to find a way to make it possible to be romantically involved with Shepard. See the difference between trying to find a way to make it possible to be romantically involved, and being romantically involved? I'm convinced she will be a romance option, but it's not confirmation. SpartHawg948 06:21, January 22, 2010 (UTC)

SPOILER WARNING! Now she's confirmed. http://www.justin.tv/clip/484ea1edf445ff4d --Kamikaz 23:45, January 22, 2010 (UTC)

Hopefully in the full version, her face can be seen..... H-Man Havoc 01:44, January 23, 2010 (UTC)

Garrus is romancible, scene here: [[1]]

Kelly Chambers

Hi, I'm mostly a lurker but I have one issue that's been bothering me. I honestly think Kelly Chambers as an option was said in jest by that one particular dev as a tongue-in-cheek remark to everyone obsessed with the romantic subplot(s) in the game (part of the forum's "culture", I suppose. From my understanding, sometimes the devs like to mess with the heads of the fans). Considering it's been theorized (or implied) that both gendered Shepards have approx. 3 options this time around and that Miranda is seen having sex with a Shepard in the 'Sci vs. Fi' preview video (which is an indicator to me that she is an option and bear in mind the Best Buy interview with Casey was *before* this clip surfaced) and that there will more than likely be a M/M romance this time around, wouldn't it be easier to not have Kelly up there for now and add her later if she really is? Would save a bit of egg on the face of the wiki, IMO. =] --Mekairinek 16:13, January 18, 2010 (UTC)

To put it frankly, no. We have a source stating that Kelly Chambers will be a romance option, and we have a suspicion/opinion on your part that she isn't. The source wins every time. For that matter, the video you claim shows Miranda having sex with Shepard... really doesn't. It shows Miranda stripping, with a brief flash of what could be Shepard's forehead, as I've pointed out several times now. As for the Best Buy Q&A, I have kept it in mind, especially the fact that Casey Hudson dodged the question of whether or not Miranda would be a romance option. His answer, when asked flat out 'Is Miranda Lawson a romance option' was "Miranda is a great "femme fatale" character. She is obviously very close with the Illusive Man, which makes it interesting for Shepard to navigate a relationship with her. As for whether she (or other characters) are romanceable, I want to let you discover that on your own." Hardly indicative. But, back to the point at hand, if you have a source stating that Kelly Chambers isn't going to be a romance option and that it's a joke, we'll have to consider which to run with. Even if it does turn out false though, I doubt we'll have egg on our faces, we were just taking what they said at face value, as we do with everything. SpartHawg948 20:09, January 18, 2010 (UTC)

Kelly isn't really a romance option like the others, 'getting' her won't grant you the Paramour achievement for example. On the other hand this doesn't exactly allow for interpretation. :p --81.191.1.103 12:16, January 29, 2010 (UTC)

Morinth as a romance

Should Morinth be considered as a viable romance option, since she can only be recruited during Samara's loyalty mission, and kills her partners afterwards? Tantalus91 15:26, January 28, 2010 (UTC)Tantalus91

Probably not, considering that there is really no extra dialogue or development besides what she has to say when you first get her. None of the dialogue changes no matter how many missions you do, until after the suicide mission of course. And because you do die after you romance her, there is really no record that you even did romance her, because you have to reload from your last save.

No extra dialogue or development? Hmmm... I'll want to take a look at whatever crystal ball you used to ascertain that there will be no added impact or record of romancing her come ME3. But, the fact remains, she is a romance option. Not the smartest romance option out there, but she is one. And we can't say that there's no development or record or anything, because for all we know, sleeping with her and getting killed will have a major impact in ME3. SpartHawg948 05:44, February 12, 2010 (UTC)

I'm not claiming to have any "crystal ball" but the fact remains that the development and dialogue change only once throughout the course of the game. And the fact is you do die, you have to reload the game from an earlier save, so technically, there is no record that you did romance her.

Regardless, just did a little fact-checking (should have done it before commenting, but better late than never!) and this whole thing is moot. The article clearly does not consider Morinth as a "viable romance option", simply noting (after the section on viable romance options) that it is possible. She gets the same treatment that Sha'ira gets in the ME section. SpartHawg948 05:49, February 12, 2010 (UTC)

Yeah, i figured it was just an easter egg type thing, something for bioware to laugh at when people are pissed off that they just died. But you are right, I don't know for sure if it will have an impact or not. Just speculating.

All Interests?

Is it possible to romance every love interest in one playthrough? (Excluding Morinth that is)

No. I don't know about the others, but Tali forces a choice. --Fiskn 04:40, February 1, 2010 (UTC)

haveing a romance with the Mass Effect1 characters kaiden or ash

I've been trying to figure out if i could still have a romance subplot with ash but it seems that is out of the question because when i first visited her on horizon she gets upset about me being gone for so long and she storms off ANGRY and then later in the game she sent me a message saying that she was sorry (i wonder if i can still have the achievement if i stick with her because i am getting ready to finish ME2 i wonder what will happen because my mass effect character was imported, could someone tell me if i would get the achievement because my chacater is still in love with her???

THIS IS AN URGENT MESSAGE

No, I am pretty sure that you have to pursue a romance option in Mass Effect 2 to get the achievment. If you want to keep your romance with Ashley in your storyline but want the achievement, you will have to start a new game after completing your current play-through and have a romance with one of the Mass Effect 2 characters

Does this work both ways? I got the achievment in my first playthrough, but I want to continue my romance with Ash. So theoretically, I can playthrough again and not romance any of the ME2 characters, effectively keeping Ash as a romance character in ME3?

Yeah, that would work too. I did the same thing, except with Liara on my second playthrough. You would just have to be sure to upload the right file to ME3. Too bad we have to wait a year.

Ms. Chambers' interests

Ms. Chambers flirts with both male and female Shepards. I've invited her up to the Captains Quarters and she accepted while playing a femShepard.

It just showed them going to the elevator, then coming back to work the "next day" with Chambers making a comment about being up late.

I just thought she was Bi.

Yes, she's quite certainly bi, this is easily evidenced in the fact that both fem and male Shepard can have Kelly dance and flirt and clean their fish tank. The only issue with it is, she doesn't count as a romance option officially, and there's no "scene" like the others before you go through Omega-4 relay, because Kelly isn't around at that time, she's also not part of your squad. Kelly also has interest in aliens of all kinds, really during your chats with her, you learn she's into anything. Jaline 02:32, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

Possible Glitch or Bug? ME2 Romance (M Sheph)

How exactly do you get the romance option, i i dont have full paragon but half way there, naer the end of the game about to go to omega 4 relay and i still havent had a opportunity for a romance relationship (I am male shepherd) i have spoken to all possible 1s and completed their missions.

It has nothing to do with renegade/paragon. It has to do with the conversations. There are certain conversation choices which will lead to romance options. SpartHawg948 04:25, February 2, 2010 (UTC)

The Picture On The Desk

Hey i read that your previous lover's (if you imported from ME1) picture is displayed in a little picture frame on your desk. Also, the picture frame is supposedly turned facedown if you pursue a new love interest in ME2. I would like to know a few things:

A) If the picture appears to be black, does that mean that your imported character had no relations in ME1?

B) If the picture is black and the above is true, does Shepard still turn the pic facedown when the new romance starts?

C) I would like confirmation as to EXACTLY where this picture is. I'm pretty sure it's the frame standing up underneath the desk lamp near the left side of the desk next to the little orange and white handheld note-displaying thingy

Please, anyone who has experience with this respond.

A) If the picture is black, but you had a relationship in ME1 walk over to it and the picture will turn on.

B) If there was no love interest before, there's no picture to turn down.

C) Yeah.

I'm not sure the responses above are correct. I just completed ME1 and my Shepard had sex with Ashley. So, I'm assuming that means I'm in (or at least was in) a relationship with her. I just converted the save file and started up an ME2 game with my imported ME1 Shepard, just got the new Normandy, and am currently standing in front of a blank/black pictureframe on my desk. I've walked right up to it and no image of Ashley appeared. So, what's up?

Bah, small mistake. There are 2 pictureframes in your cabin. The ME1 interest appears in the one on the desk immediately adjacent to the bathroom. Perhaps the one on the desk that's closer to the clock/stereo will hold the ME2 interest.

ME2 Opposite Gender Problems?

Okay, so I don't know if it's just me, or if it's something completely related to romance.. My issue is that it seems that all the females on board (aside from Kelly) completely ignore my female Shepard, not in the meaning of me trying to romance them, but just in general, because they don't speak too much at all.

On my first play, Tali completely ignored me after her loyalty quest, I would complete missions, come back, be able to chat with Mordin, Grunt, Jacob, perfectly fine, they'd chat about their stuff and all, however Tali would completely ignore me, saying she has work to do. I'm not sure where I messed up with her to shut her out, because I did her loyalty quest perfectly, with paragon options, and without getting her exiled or messing up her father. She just wouldn't talk to me anymore.

The same thing happened with Garrus, where if I didn't initiate his romance line (as in tell him I wasn't talking about sparring, and saying we could test reach & flexibility, that he just told me he has work to do.) I'm not sure that it's because these two are from ME and you learned all about them back then, or if it's because they lock out *very* easily from talking to you.

Also Jack won't talk to my female Shepard much after the loyalty quest, she asks why I keep coming down to talk to her, and I tell her "I'm curious about you" and she just tells me she's not a girl's club, and just continues to tell me to piss off for the rest of the game, even when I had picked her over Miranda in their little fight. Miranda didn't talk to me much in my last game either, but I think that's because I got her loyal again so late in the game, not sure.

Anyways, yeah, I just find it exceptionally odd, why does Mordin, Grunt, Jacob, have no problem at all chatting with me, in fact Jacob I found it *hard* to avoid getting a relationship with him, because if you choose paragon options he seems to develop a crush, if you choose renegade, he seems to start getting closer to you, so no real idea why he kept talking to me. Anyway, my question is: Does being female Shepard drop a bunch of conversation from Jack and Tali, or do they just not talk much after their loyalty quests? And Garrus too, if you're not in a relationship with him, you can't talk to him?

Thane talked to me quite a bit strangely enough, I never started a relationship with him, but chatted with me lots, same with Jacob, is Garrus different because he and Shepard are so familiar anyways? I'm just thinking it's all weird because it cuts off a lot of options to get more renegade/paragon I would think, since you can't talk to these people anymore, Mordin/Grunt/Thane/Jacob all get me some morality by chatting casually with them, but the rest ignore me completely and I wasn't able to get morality from them due to that. Jaline 02:46, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

As a male Shepard, Garrus stopped talking to me after his loyalty mission and Jacob did once and now always says he's good. Jack stopped talking to me after I did the "nasty" with her before her loyalty mission using pure Renegade options. Miranda stopped talking to me after apologizing instead of kissing her after her loyalty mission. I made it a point before starting to play that I would romance Tali and no one else. Jack was just for the sex, not the relationship :P. Besides, she's the one who wanted it :O.

Anyway, I have yet to complete the other loyalty missions, so I can't comment on that. But it does seems that once their loyalty mission is done is when they have no more to talk about. --ArmeniusLOD 02:57, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

I don't think it has anything to do with gender. Jack had 4 or 5 different convos with my fem ship before she was tired of talking. I think Tali and Garrus don't have many convos because of the familiarity factor. Matt 2108 03:00, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

I'm not sure, characters like Grunt and Mordin talked to me a lot after their loyalty missions on my first time through, however on my second play now, they've talked to me the same conversations before their loyalty missions, this is likely because I'm going back and back over and over to make sure I get the conversations, example: Mordin's sang for me after completing 2 more missions after doing his loyalty quest this time around, however on the first time around, Mordin didn't sing until after a bunch of N7 missions were completed when I was finishing up stuff pre-IFF. I can understand Garrus/Tali having short conversation paths, though I really wish they had more, since they're really interesting characters, Jack I wish had more, since she's another interesting character, but she suddenly goes quiet, even though she's extremely open in talking to you early on after getting her, completely opposite of Grunt/Mordin who take a while to exhaust their chat options, and will talk to you for quite a while, but it seems that with them it's like that because they have no romance options. Also strangely I even managed to get Mordin to give me the sex talk when I wasn't starting a relationship with any male NPCs, though I guess maybe my chats with Jacob got close, like I said, it's hard to talk to him without him hitting on you, or Shepard being very forward. Jaline 03:32, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

I actually just had a long talk with Tali after her loyalty quest – in fact, I thought it was a bug and I was getting male-Shepard dialogue. For anyone keeping score at home, she started by calling the drive core a "bosh'tet", explaining that she had a fever, then finally saying she'd totes link suits with Shepard. But then, I don't think I talked to her after every single storyline mission like you do with people in ME1 – I only started doing that after I'd finished her loyalty mission (because it was pretty much my favourite mission). She seemed pretty flirty though, especially at the end. ShepardWhyThisJubilee 05:25, February 8, 2010 (UTC)

ME2 keeping ME1 love interest, Miranda as friend until saving galaxy

Hey, I saved the game just before the talk with Miranda where you can confirm your love interest with her (so your old love interest picture is faced down) and through the dialog you can agree with her to keep being friends along the mission, instead of starting the relationship. Does this mean that you have the choice to consumate the relationship after finishing the suicide mission (this is my second playthrough) or ignoring it and deciding what to do in Mass Effect 3? Armenek 00:38, February 8, 2010 (UTC)

Shepard and the Omega 4 scene.

I noticed the article says Shepard smiles at the picture if you keep faithful to your ME1 romance. This is not true. If you remain faithful, but get close to a romance lock-in for ME2, Shepard will actually frown during the cutscene. Torinir 23:32, February 8, 2010 (UTC)

Ohh, I see. This could answer my previous question. I suppose you are left with the choice for Mass Effect 3. Cool. Good to know. Depending on how acts the other part that does not appear in ME2 (ME1 had a weak acting around this issue in my opinion :P). Armenek 23:51, February 8, 2010 (UTC)

Well, I can confirm this scene. It happened to me too, in my second playthrough. I had Miranda close to a romance lock-in. As I said before, via dialog options it ended in an agreement for being friends until saving the galaxy, which I think it includes Mass Effect 3, because once the Suicide Misison is completed and you go back to the Normandy, talking with Miranda gives the "There's much work to do" response. And I have to add that before the scene frowning towards Ash's photograph, Miranda remarks that she hopes to see Shepard in the other side (and you can answer you hope too or that you don't mind or else), and I think in my first playthrought in which I romanced her she didn't to that, she advised him to go to the engine room. So the "picture being faced down" could be more explained (it can be put again in it's original position by telling Miranda you are not interested after lock-in her in and before the romance scene if you don't agree to remain friends). I don't know if this could work for other romances, but it should. Armenek 17:25, February 10, 2010 (UTC)

Shepard doesn't seem to be making a particular expression. I've seen several videos of it, and it never looks like a smile or a frown. I don't think the game wanted to pick what you felt at that moment. I'll also point out that your choice of lips effects what you see.HelterSkelter 17:55, February 19, 2010 (UTC)

May be, my Shepard's face was, by default, a little serious hehe =). Armenek 18:03, February 19, 2010 (UTC)

(ME2) Post Collector Base Romance

I screwed up on the Romance subplot in my first playthrough and didn't attempt a romance until directly before hopping through the Omega 4 Relay (when I initiated with Garrus). Obviously, since there is an additional round of dialogue, this didn't trigger the cutscene or the achievement immediately. After finishing the game, I approached Garrus again and got the other set of dialogue (not sure if it is or isn't the same one for before hitting the node) and as soon as I finished that dialogue, it jumped immediately to the Captain's quarters for the romance climax. Paramour was unlocked in the process. --forgottenlord 16:55, February 11, 2010 (UTC)

Unwanted Romance

I recently finished playing through ME1 and imported my Shepard over to ME2. Since I wanted to get to know Ashley but didn't want to romance her, I carried the relationship up to the point where she attempts to comfort you after the Council spouts its bullshit at you right before Ilos, at which point I rejected her and thus avoided the private encounter in his room (I also told Liara that Ashley and I were just friends, but I don't think that changed anything). Unfortunately, after a few hours into ME2, I went up to the captain's room and found Ashley's picture waiting for me; on Horizon, she talked about loving me; and after Horizon, she inevitably sent the message in which she speaks of "our night" which I already mentioned never happened. I also found someone with a similar problem: this other player also wanted to avoid romancing Ashley, so he went through an entire game in which he talked down to her the entire time, and still her picture stubbornly popped up in his cabin when he got to ME2. I would like to know, is this a bug, or are we doing something wrong? Is there a solution, short of completely ignoring both Ashley and Liara during the whole of ME1 (or killing off Ashley on Virmire)? Scathelock 04:26, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

I was recently curious about this... so I did the following -- I played a femshep and did not talk to Kaidan the ENTIRE game. Then I spoke to him ONCE right before the council and the BS before Ilos, and if you pick paragon options, the conversation will end with "do you take the time to get this personal with everyone?", and NO MATTER WHAT I PICK, I say some variety of "no, just you." Even if I pick the renegade option. To which he says "I'll have to take time to process that." Well, apparently he didn't need any time at all, because he was sleeping with my Shepard. The only way to de-rail him from saying "do you get this personal with all your crew?" and thus get into an irreversible romantic situation was to pick a renegade option near the end of the dialogue, which caused Shepard to say something like "I gave up waiting for the good part." Basically, don't talk to them. Ever. Or if you do, you have to be mean. Otherwise the game pretty much forces them into your quarters for some sweet sweet loving. It's lame, I know, but the solutions you mentioned are the only ones -- ignoring, or killing your chosen love interest. --Lilliful 00:27, February 17, 2010 (UTC)

You can't egg Ashley or Kaidan along, you have to nip it in the bud during the first conversation after the first plot world. Yeah, saying "I gave up waiting for the good part." to Kaidan is the only way to get him to stop hitting on you. You can be nice to him for every other convo option though. :p Matt 2108 04:39, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

After doing that, did his picture not show up for you in ME2? Above, Scathelock seems to have had the problem that he was mean to Ashley the whole game and there was no consummation, but the picture still cropped up :( --Lilliful 10:15, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

Kaidan's picture has never showed up, whether he died on Virmire or lived. I don't have experience with Ashley because I don't play male sheps (not a Mark Meer fan). Matt 2108 21:11, February 18, 2010 (UTC)

Killing the Love Interest?

I recently started playing Mass Effect 1 (I wasn't happy with the default settings for ME2) as FemShep, and I don't want a romance with Kaidan - don't really want all the guilt when I go after Garrus, and I don't find him attractive anyway - so I've been avoiding talking to him between missions. However, I gave him a Paragon response after Eden Prime - does this mean the game will place a picture of him on my desk on ME2? And, if that means yes, can I kill him on Virmire and not have the picture? -Archaeic 18:23, February 20, 2010 (UTC)

I do not know if only that response will mean he becomes romancable, but yes killing him means no picture. Badly Browned 04:54, February 24, 2010 (UTC)

In Mass Effect, the romance is complete when you have the scene on the way to Ilos. Virmire is before Ilos. If Kaidan is killed on Virmire, then that means there can be no romance scene with Kaidan on the way to Ilos. So yeah, you'll achieve your goal. —Seburo 05:02, February 24, 2010 (UTC)

Excellent, because I just killed him on Virmire. Heartless, I know, but them's the breaks. -Archaeic 16:12, February 25, 2010 (UTC)

ME2 love triangle

What exactly happens when you have a love triangle in ME2? Like if you have someone 'locked in' and go for someone else, or if you just flirt with two (or three?) potential love interests at the same time. Are there cutscenes like in ME when they come to 'talk' to you? Are you forced to choose one or does it work some other way? Kiadony 08:22, March 15, 2010 (UTC)

What happens in Mass Effect 2 if you romance Kaiden or Ashley AND pick them to stay and die in Mass Effect 1?

ME2

That is alot of romances, at this point i think it would have been easier to have just wrote down the word everyone in place of the entire me2 romance section, butthat is just me trying to be funny at4 in the morning. Seriously though that is alot, and i think the only reason everyone else wasnt included was for age reaasons, wierd. ralok 08:21, April 4, 2010 (UTC)